New Loot Rules

[taallonn]

Hello guildies
This poll is for the expansion Wrath of the Lich King. It is not for the way loot is handled currently in the burning Crusade. I would ask that those without a current WoW account refrain from voting; however your opinion is always welcome.
There are 2 options for this poll.

Number 1: loot is handled the way it is now. Random 100 roll for those that need an item
Number 2: Loot is based off an attendance to raids.

Proposal: I would like to propose that we change the way loot is currently handled. I and others have been frustrated in past raids to see items walk out the door so to speak. Players that show up for 1 raid win a tier item and then leave the guild. The loot system I will propose will help curb this.
There will be 3 classifications of raiders:
Casual: When an item drops they roll 1-100 for the item
Casual Raider: Will roll 25-100 for the item
Raider: Will roll 50-100 for the item

Classifications are based on attendance and sign ups. If you are in 3 raids in 1 month you are a raider. If you are in 1 raid in 1 month you are a casual raider. If you have not been in a raid in a month you are a casual.
Loot as far as 1 item per run and 1 tier item per run per person will stay the same (unless of course you are the only person that can use that item), no matter which choice is accepted.

[xyon]

At first when I started reading this my tought was hell no I like it the way it is.

But I decided to read it fully before making my mind. Now that I have read it I must say that I like your proposal. I do not have a lot of time to raid. I can only make it on fridays and saturdays and that's if I do not have more important social stuff coming up. So basicly I can only raid once or twice a week. In most raid guilds that's considered casual.

But since SWP has never been and will never be a true raid guild I like the way you worded it. It only takes me 3 raids in a month to be considered a raider... sweet. ;D

[jenner]

You all should know my opinion now, if someone is in a raid/dungeon crawl and something drops, they should be have a chance at it, for they were there and made it possible. It should never be based on how often you raid/dungeon crawl. The Person is part of the guild and anything that helps them helps make the guild stronger.

[jenner]

as long as no names are called, I will not delete post. I have had to delete a couple because of it.

[zuggy]

My opinion is if I've been healing our raid for 3 months waiting on a drop to come and some newbie level 80 toon comes in and gets what I've been waiting for because blizzards fucked up randomizer screws me with a 1 then I'm gonna be pissed and most likely would not say anything but would be reluctant to go back to heal.

In case you don't realize from my post I like the proposal of the new loot rules.


BIack

[killarouge]

i like the propsal for the new loot rules for wolk

[laileb]

sounds good